Playing from 1990-94, Todd Pautz was a member of Judson's first-ever NCCAA National Tournament Championship team as a sophomore in 1991. In 1992 the team repeated as champions and he was named the Tournament Most Valuable Player, one of just five Judson players to ever receive that honor. A four-time NIIC All-Conference selection and Conference Player of the Year as a junior, Pautz holds the program's record for most assists in a game with six and is ranked third all-time with 73 career assists. He was his team's leader in assists in his final three seasons with his highest season total of 23 assists coming as a senior, the fifth best single-season mark for the program. He also ranks in the top-10 with 22 assists as a junior and 20 assists as a sophomore. Pautz was a NAIA Honorable Mention All-American, a NCCAA All-American, NCCAA All-District and NAIA All-Area selection as both a junior and a senior.