Weissman is one of a few Hall of Famers to make a significant impact for multiple athletic programs. In women's volleyball, she is a three-time NCCAA All-region player and a two-time NCCAA 2nd Team All-American (2006 & 2007). In 2009, she was a CCAC All-Conference First Team Member and was honorable mention All-conference in 2006 and 2007. Weissman is first all-time in Judson history in digs with 2681 and digs per game with 5.74. She is third overall with 181 service aces. In softball, Weissman was a two-time NCCAA All-American, two-time CCAC first team, two-time NCCAA All-Region and a 2007 NCCAA National Tournament Team Member. Despite only playing two years, she is sixth in program history with 18 home runs. In 2008, she was the Judson University Female Athlete of the Year.